Thanks for the replies. I will try to detail my experiments better in the future.
We do standard tryptic digests, both in gel and in solution, using 50 mM ammonium bicarbonate, reduce and alkylate using DTT and IAA, and then quench the trypsin reaction using formic acid to .1%. All of this is done exclusively in LoBind tubes from eppendorf. After digestion is complete I dry down the samples and bring them up in 95/5 water/acn with .1% formic acid. I then pack ~5-10% of the sample directly on a tip using a pressure bomb. This greatly reduces the amount of carry over from previous runs because the sample is not being injected into the sample loop. We have been getting great results, except for the very large contaminant peaks.
Since we pull and pack our own columns, and it is very inexpensive, we use a new column for every sample to ensure the greatest sample integrity possible. The 453 and 679 are by far the 2 biggest peaks in every run, sometimes baselining other peaks that otherwise would be considered quite large. Also, the concentration of the 2 contaminant peaks holds relatively steady for each sample run.
When I run a blank after a sample run using the same column, the run is completely blank, with no peaks showing up. The method I use for the blanks is the exact same method I use for the samples so I can see if the peaks still come out. This is why I believe it must be something in my sample and not the LC solvents.
Also, when I was troubleshooting the problem, I packed a C18 column with no sample packed on it and ran my method to check if it could possibly be a contaminant within the C18. However, this came back completely blank. I also packed 95/5 water/acn with .1% formic acid on the tip and ran that to see if it was a contaminant within the buffer I use to reconstitute my sample. Again, this came back completely blank.
All of this leads me to believe it must be something that happens while digesting, but I cannot figure out what it could possibly be, since we do not use nylon at all in our digestion protocol.
I hope this helps describe my problem a bit more. If you have any more questions please post them and I will try to give you more details. Thanks a lot for the responses.